Apple HomeView Review: Great Hardware Trapped in a Walled Clock

The Apple playbook is known to all by now. ‘Don’t rush into a new category and do it last, but do it right.’ Right? Well, the HomeView isn’t the first in the category and definitely hasn’t got everything right. So what gives? Let’s find out.

At Rs 39,900, the HomeView has the unmistakable Apple polish and even a bit of nostalgia. Powered by an A18 chip behind a 7-inch square Liquid Retina screen, it sits on your desk or kitchen counter as an entertainment hub, AI companion, and smart home brain. The hinged screen, though, is instantly reminiscent of the iMac G4 and works with the perfect weight and damping that is commensurate with its price tag. The thick bezels, though, are very 2016 iPad, or early Apple Watches. In fact, as an owner of the Daily Objects Node wireless charger and Apple Watch, the HomeView does have a strong possible resemblance to an Apple Clock on a charging dock.

Table of Contents

Design (8/10)

Sitting on an aluminium speaker base and a cantilevered display resting on a stainless steel hinge undoubtedly gives the HomeView a very premium feel. The playful watch-style faces also include Snoopy, one of my favourites that can brighten up any desk. The crisp 1088×1088 display hits 500 nits in brightly lit rooms but will drop to 0.3 nits for nighttime duty, and all the home screen animations transition from daytime to nighttime beautifully into dark mode.

While its 1:1 aspect ratio works brilliantly as a smart-home interface and for video calling, watching any 16:9 aspect ratio video content will result in heavy letterboxing, reducing the viewable screen area significantly. FaceTime video calls shine on the 12MP Centre Stage camera, though it’s clear that it is meant to be locked within the Apple ecosystem with no support for WhatsApp video calling. There’s no physical button to switch off the mic or camera, mind you. In fact, no way to switch them off at all, but Apple doesn’t store anything in the cloud, and even on-device processing is only temporary through the Secure Enclave.

The lack of any physical buttons means that every small change to volume and brightness will have to be done via summoning Siri or swiping down from the top right, like on an iPhone. Since this was designed to be a dual-purpose unit with wall-mounting being part of the aesthetic, perhaps that could be the reason. Strangely, prices for the desktop version with a 5-driver system and the wall-mounted version with just the display are identical. Additionally, you’ll have to pony up for the USB-C/POE adapter mounts. The tabletop version’s base packs two full-range drivers, a down-firing woofer, and dual passive radiators and makes a much better case for value.

Side note though: I had the Amazon Echo Show 8 on hand and on the same desk, and it sounded considerably more immersive with a much wider stereo image and richer bass than the HomeView.

Siri AI (6/10)

For a product that was designed primarily around voice control, one can imagine how important Siri AI is for the HomeView, and this is where the friction piles up. First, there is too much of a good thing if you have an iPhone 18 Pro Max nearby and an Apple Watch Series 12 on your wrist. Summoning Siri promptly wakes both devices, while HomeView plays dead unless you’re directly looking at it and it’s closer to you than the other two devices. You’ll have to get used to keeping your iPhone face down if it’s too close to the HomeView. Even if your phone is unlocked from a recent activity and you speak to the HomeView, Siri on the iPhone is triggered. Even when it does respond, Siri AI feels sluggish and trips easily over follow-up commands.

The Recipe mode is a genuine highlight, though, breaking cooking down into clear step-by-step cards with dedicated timers for every stage. You will have to ask to show a recipe specifically in Safari and then tap on the little icon on the bottom right to get into that specific mode.

Apple’s decision to skip the App Store for the HomeView is a baffling one. Instead, compatible CarPlay apps are automatically ported from the partnering iPhone, which also handles the Siri AI heavy lifting. I’m still trying to fathom the rationale behind using CarPlay as a sandbox here. Why would a stationary desktop display need to borrow the same apps that are optimised for driving use?

Even the limited number of ported apps behave erratically. The NDTV app was showing up on the HomeView screen, yet Siri AI refused to acknowledge it existed, ignoring voice requests for live news and forcing manual taps. Safari lets you pull up YouTube, sure, but only one tab at a time. So it’s not exactly meant for browsing. More often than not, it feels like the early iPad era, where great hardware sat chained to limited software. Once you do get the videos playing on any of the apps, it is a fun way to catch up on shows, news, podcasts or FaceTime calls while in the kitchen or busy with chores around the room, and that truly seems to be the biggest use case of the HomeView. Casual viewing, listening or catching up as a secondary activity.

Special mention must be made for Apple Music, which is nicely optimised to fill the display with animated cover art, which is almost the same size as a CD cover. For fans of physical media, this could bring them one step closer to their favourite music. Apple TV works well too but in 16:9 aspect ratio content, the viewable display area is as only as big as an iPhone 18 Pro Max.

HomeView supports six face-and-voice profiles, and Apple promises personal messages only surface when your unlocked iPhone is nearby. But thanks to modern reality, convincing family members, especially teenagers, to add their profiles to a shared kitchen screen proved to be tough. Apple’s Secure Enclave ensures camera or mic feeds are stored anywhere and only processed on-device momentarily. But fears of accidental background logins and clunky profile switching when two people stand in frame prevented anyone from risking personal texts flashing next to the coffee maker.

Smart Home Performance (6/10)

With HomeKit, Matter, Thread, and support for up to nine live camera feeds, HomeView’s usefulness boils down to how many compatible lights, locks, and doorbells you already own. In India, that lineup is both sparse and expensive. Apple’s HomeView launch partners, LG and Schneider Home, have yet to launch their smart accessories locally, and even the Rs 39,900 wall-mounted model needs separate Schneider power mounts starting at Rs 6,900. If you don’t have an existing ecosystem of Matter, Thread or HomeKit-compatible devices, you may feel tempted to buy compatible gadgets just to justify HomeView. Advanced smart home users and professional installers will still rely on Crestron, Lutron, or Savant controllers, and until they get access to an App Store for dedicated installer apps, HomeView remains confined to the interoperability layer.

MyDyson app allows me to control the air purifiers in different rooms with iPhone Shortcuts, but Siri AI on the HomeView won’t control them, possibly because it needs a Homebridge in the signal path. And it referred to itself in the error message as a “HomePod”. Also, if you use Google services like Gmail and Google Calendar, there’s no way you can give it access to those. Instead, you will have to link them to Apple’s own Calendar and Mail apps before you start seeing genuine usefulness. But, considering the HomeView’s target audience is hardcore Apple users, this won’t be an issue.

Verdict

At Rs 20,000, HomeView would be a fun Apple ecosystem perk in the same vein as the Apple TV was when it first came out. But at nearly Rs 40,000, it is a gorgeous, overpriced toy with somewhat limited utility at the moment. Unless Apple allows access to an App Store, it will remain a niche gadget or coax you into upgrading your home with more compatible smart things.

Editor’s Rating: 6.5 / 10

Pros

Cons

Home Reviews